← All guides
For small businesses · Instagram Auto DM

Instagram comment replies and DMs: what should you say in each?

Use a Mumbai bakery’s menu reel to decide when a public reply helps, what belongs in the DM, and how to check each reply separately.

Set it up in Leadlio

  1. Give the public reply one job

    Imagine two people under your cake reel. One comments “MENU” and the other asks “Do you deliver to Bandra?” For MENU, a short “I’ve sent the cake menu to your inbox” tells the first person where to look. Answer the Bandra question in the thread if the answer would help everyone. Save a customer’s exact address and order details for a private conversation.

  2. Put the promised answer in the first DM

    Select the menu reel and enter MENU under “Keywords, separated by commas”. Leave Advanced DM off for this example. Paste the sample into “DM sent to the commenter”, replace the placeholder with your menu URL, and open it on a signed-out phone. A reader should be able to see the sizes and prices before answering your question.

  3. Decide whether a public acknowledgement helps

    For this reel, select “Also reply publicly after the DM is sent”. Choose “Edit replies” and give each variation the same promise. “Your cake menu is in your DMs 🍰” works; “Your cake is booked” promises something nobody has confirmed. Leadlio picks one variation after a successful DM. Select “Confirm replies”, then enable and save the automation. For a reel where an acknowledgement would add clutter, leave the public option off.

  4. Check the comment and the inbox separately

    On a test reel, comment MENU from another account. Check the reply beneath that comment and open the menu link in the DM. In Leadlio, open “Activity & replies” and use “Search activity” to find the test username. Read “First DM” and “Public reply” on the same row. If the first says “Sent” and the second says “Failed”, investigate the missing public reply before sending another copy of the menu.

If either status says “Delivery unconfirmed”, check that part of the conversation in Instagram before replying manually. A “Sent” DM records a send, so use the test account to check that the link opens the intended menu.

Open Leadlio to set this up →